← All postsPerson using Ideal Weight Calculator on a laptop for a real general fitness planning task

What Four Ideal Weight Formulas Say About One Height

Compare the Devine, Robinson, Miller and Hamwi estimates side by side, see why they differ, and use the results as a rough reference only.

ideal weight calculatorhealth calculatorsDevine formulabody weight referenceBMI rangeFreeDailyProfitness planningbrowser tools
5 min readHealth Calculators

Ask four formulas for an "ideal" weight at the same height and you get four different answers. That is not a bug. It is the most honest thing about this kind of calculator. Ideal Weight Calculator shows the four classic estimates next to each other, plus a range based on BMI, so you can see how much agreement there is before you take any single number seriously.

The clip below shows the calculator in use.

Calculate ideal body weight online

Calculate ideal body weight online

What the tool asks for and shows

You enter only two things: a sex (Male or Female tab) and a height. A toggle switches between metric (kg and cm) and imperial (lb and feet plus inches), and your height is converted when you flip it. Heights between 100 and 250 cm are accepted; typing 1.70 into the centimetre box prompts you to enter centimetres instead.

The results show four boxes, one each for the Devine, Robinson, Miller and Hamwi formulas, a large Average of the four, and a line giving the weight range that corresponds to a BMI of 18.5 to 24.9 at your height. Imperial results are rounded to whole pounds, and metric ones show one decimal place. Everything is calculated in your browser from those two inputs.

A worked example at 165 cm

Take a woman who is 165 cm tall (about 5 feet 5 inches). The four formulas give:

  • Devine: 56.9 kg
  • Robinson: 57.4 kg
  • Miller: 59.8 kg
  • Hamwi: 56.4 kg

The average is 57.7 kg, or about 127 lb. The BMI line reads 50.4 to 67.8 kg (111 to 149 lb). Notice the gap in scale: the formulas cluster within about 3.4 kg of each other, while the BMI range spans more than 17 kg. They answer different questions. The formulas give a single point; the BMI band says what falls in a conventional "normal" category for height.

Now a man at 180 cm. Devine gives 75.0 kg, Robinson 72.6, Miller 71.5 and Hamwi 77.3. The average is 74.1 kg (about 163 lb), and the BMI range is 59.9 to 80.7 kg. Again the formulas sit in a 5.8 kg band, nested well inside the BMI range.

Why the formulas disagree

All four start from a base weight at 5 feet and add a fixed amount for every inch above it. They differ in the base and the slope. For a man, Devine starts at 50 kg and adds 2.3 kg per inch, while Miller starts at 56.2 kg and adds only 1.41 kg per inch. That is why Miller gives a heavier answer for shorter people and a lighter one for taller people, and why those two lines cross at about 5 feet 7 inches.

They also date from the 1960s to the 1980s. Devine (1974) was originally published for drug dosing, not for fitness goals. Hamwi (1964) and the others are population-average rules of thumb, built from the data and the body-size norms of their time. None of them knows anything about you beyond height and sex.

The short-height quirk

Because each formula adds weight only for inches above 5 feet, anyone under 152.4 cm (60 inches) gets the base number from every formula, however short they are. For a man at 152 cm the results are Devine 50.0, Robinson 52.0, Miller 56.2 and Hamwi 48.0 kg, an average of 51.5 kg; the answer at 150 cm is identical. If you are under 5 feet, lean on the BMI range line instead, and notice that the formulas have little to say.

How to use the output sensibly

  1. Enter your height in the units you know, and choose the tab that matches the formula constants you want to see.
  2. Look at the spread of the four formulas. A tight cluster means the answer is stable; a wide spread means you should treat the average loosely.
  3. Compare the average with the BMI range line. If your current weight sits inside the range, the formulas are not telling you much; if far outside, they are one more prompt to talk with a professional.
  4. Record the range, not a single number. Something like "57 to 60 kg" is a more truthful reference than "57.7".
  5. For a fuller picture, add body composition from Body Fat Calculator and the standard index from BMI Calculator.

Where these numbers mislead

Muscle weighs more than fat, so a strength athlete can land far above every figure and be in excellent condition. People with a larger or smaller frame than average are not accounted for. The formulas were designed for adults and were published with separate male and female constants, which is why the tool asks you to pick one. Age, ethnicity, health conditions and body fat distribution are not inputs at all. This is general information, not medical advice, and the tool itself says the same.

For a goal that involves your health, such as a weight loss or gain target, a doctor or registered dietitian can interpret measurements in context. A calculator cannot.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the average as a target. It is the middle of four old rules of thumb, not a prescription.
  • Mixing up the two imperial boxes. Typing 5.5 in the feet box means five and a half feet, so for 5 ft 5 in enter 5 in the feet box and 5 in the inches box.
  • Ignoring the BMI line because it is wide. Its width is the point: healthy weights vary a lot between people of the same height.
  • Using the result for a child or teenager. These formulas are for adult heights.
  • Comparing against someone else's result. A friend's calculation at a different height says nothing about yours.

A sensible next step

Run your own height, write down the four numbers and the BMI range, and keep them as context rather than a goal. If you also track calories, the wider health calculators category has tools for energy needs and hydration.

What would make this comparison more useful for you, a different set of formulas or a clearer explanation of the BMI band? Tell us on the contact page.

Open Ideal Weight CalculatorOpen BMI CalculatorOpen Body Fat Calculator